Source verification: “50 of the protesters Israel killed were Hamas fighters”

The statement that 50 of the protesters killed at the Gaza Strip border by Israel military were actually Hamas members, was disputed by many news organizations, picked up by many others and is a classic example of the importance of finding Patient Zero for determining the trustworthiness of an information.

Last week (May 14th 2018) the relocation of the US Embassy to Jerusalem sparked a series of protests at the Gaza Strip border, resulting in the death of over 60 Palestinian protesters. As many newspapers worldwide were decrying the deadly shootings of Palestinians by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF), the information that many of those killed by the border guards were actually members of Hamas, a Palestinian terrorist group, started making the rounds. The source of the information was difficult to track, as even Wikileaks and WikiTribune founder Jimmy Wales was taking on Twitter asking for help to determine the source of this information:

With the latest TrustServista 2.0 release, the new redesigned Web Dashboard now has a complete set of tools to perform news verification and analysis in a matter of minutes.

For this story, the source of information was actually a message from the official Twitter account IDFSpokeperson, using as a source a part of a video interview (in Arabic)  from Baldana Facebook page of as senior Hamas representative Dr. Salah Al-Bardawil. However, the actual translation from Arabic has not been verified, and the video statement is taken out of context from a 1-hour long video interview.


How to perform a Patient Zero investigation with TrustServista

For any web article, the easiest way to verify its content and find its Patient Zero is by using the TrustServista Chrome Extension, but using the TrustServista Web Dashboard will provide more tools for analytics purposes.

Using the Web Dashboard multipurpose search function reveals when the story surrounding the Gaza protests hit a high, in regards to the volume of content produced:

Searching for the Hamas official’s name (Salah Al-Bardawil, Salah Albardawil) finds 62 articles published between May 16th and 21st, with an overwhelmingly negative tone (92%).

For example, analyzing this article from Fox News (Hamas admits most killed in Gaza violence were its members) reveals more sources of information, all coming from Twitter:

Some referenced tweets are from German BILD journalist Björn Stritzel (verified Twitter account), who also posts images or killed Palestinian protesters in military uniforms, confirming the IDF information that they were actually members of Hamas.


Tagged with:

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.